Thursday, 5 August 2010

Animal cruelty - are we hypocrites?

There is no excuse for animal cruelty. Animal cruelty directed at cats, dogs, donkeys and other family pets always produces an outrage from concerned community, and rightly so! A kitten kicked around a railway station, a kitten hung from a Gold Coast fence with fishing line, dogs mistreated, donkeys neglected, kangaroo joeys left to die when their mothers are shot for meat - these incidents screen on the nightly news while we are eating our evening meal, and we are all sickened. If we weren't sickened by these cruel acts, there would be something amiss with our human makeup.

But what's on our plate for our evening meal? A tender, healthy chicken breast? Or chicken nuggets for the kids? Or a crispy chicken schnitzel burger from the local takeaway?

We all know how inhumanely Australian chicken products are grown - we live in an age where information is freely available. Chicken meat comes from cruel factory farms. Broiler chickens can legally be confined to a density that gives each bird less space than a single A4 sheet of paper. Just imagine the outroar if a pet owner was discovered keeping pets in such an unacceptable manner!

Chickens are bred to grow three times faster than nature intended - the birds are slaughtered at just six weeks of age, producing the large, plump breasts we purchase at the supermarket deli or butcher shop. So heavy is their weight, that their immature skeleton often gives way and the bird dies where it falls unable to drink or eat. And it is also reported that millions of these unnaturally heavy birds die of heart failure.

We humans are removed from the actual acts of cruelty, but we actively contribute, by purchasing the products. This, however, rarely occurs to us as we sit in front of the television and condemn those who have been discovered treating pets and domestic animals cruelly.

Eggs - we all know that Australian mass produced eggs come from thoroughly disgusting places: battery hens spend their laying life in a cage crammed with up to four other birds; each hen stands on a space smaller than an A4 sheet of paper; this space is a bare cage with thin sloping wire underfoot. Tiered rows and rows of these cages are housed in huge artificially lit sheds, with no fresh air and no sunlight.

Fortunately, we now have the opportunity to purchase more ethically produced eggs and chicken meat. But when we buy a packet of biscuits, or piece of cake with our coffee, or countless other products on the market, we are eating battery farmed eggs, and thus, contributing to the cruel treatment of the hens.

Again, we all know this, yet we separate one act of animal cruelty from another, choosing to ignore our part in everyday animal cruelty, while condemning someone else.

And pork! The horrific conditions in which Australian pork is bred is periodically reported by animal activists to remind consumers. Pregnant sows are housed in individual metal stalls with concrete floors that are barely bigger than the body of the animal. The pig is unable to even turn around. She has to feed her young in this condition, with no chance to nurture and bond with her young. Sows are continually impregnated until their bodies can no longer physically cope.

What's on our plate at dinner time? A delicious grilled pork loin chop? A luscious leg of ham for our Christmas gathering? Eggs and bacon for Sunday brunch?

We'll tuck into our beautiful meal without a thought for our part in the unimaginable daily animal cruelty of producing these food items. And yet, we will be sickened and struck with disbelief at hearing of or seeing pets etc subjected to cruelty. Yes, we are hypocrites.

4 comments:

Tricia said...

Hear Hear Gaye!!

Yes, we are hypocrites. We all know the facts....but we prefer to ignore them. I have been surprised by the reaction animal activists get from the general public. They are often sadly regarded as anoying extremists. We don't like being reminded of horrible conditions our 'food' lives in.

Thank you for the reminder Gaye.

I don't intentionally buy farmed meat or caged eggs. Instead we try and buy only sustainably harvested wild meat (e.g. Kangaroo or sustainable seafood) and free range organic eggs. I know these animals have lived a happy life (although I also know that I took them away from this happy life).

I also know we unintentionally support factory farming - as you point out - through the packet of biscuits I have sitting in my desk draw. Or the take-away dinner we buy on a busy night.

I try not to feel bad and just tell myself - atleast I am aware and know there are better choices I could have made. And over time these 'better choices' outweigh the 'poor' choices.

Tricia
x

Gaye from the Hunter said...

Hello Tricia,

I have been making more poor choices than good choices lately, so am making an effort to change my behaviour. I go through periods of really being careful about the ethical standards of the food I buy, and then I slip back into what's easy, ie. hurriedly buying what I need all in the one supermarket. I need to stop every now and then and remind myself where my food is coming from.

I really do become annoyed when people self-righteously declare that such-n-such is a disgraceful human being because of an act of animal cruelty, while that person takes little to no responsibility to avoid food that is produced using animal cruelty. Animal cruelty is animal cruelty whether that animal is a pet cat, or a chicken that ends up on our dinner table.

It's very difficult to always eat with a clear conscience. Take milk as another example - when I lived in rural Hunter Valley a year ago, I would hear a cow bellowing all day and all night for her 1 or 2 day-old calf that was taken from her. A dairy cow grieves and frets just any other mammal that has her baby taken off her.

We humans have a lot of misdoings to answer for.

Thank you for your comment, Tricia.

Cheers,
Gaye

Somewhat inspired said...

Hi Gaye,

This is a great post. Apparently some of the battery farmed chickens get osteoporosis, so they may also be in terrible pain.

I go through the same conflicts. I buy Lilydale free range chicken from the market, but I buy free range eggs from Woolworths, and there's a shocking lack of regulation around this category - I really would like to see the conditions on the farms producing Woolworths free range eggs.

And then there's wool, which I've recently started buying again - I stopped for a while, after seeing a freshly shorn herd of sheep in an open field huddling together for warmth on a rainy winters day.

It really is a case of 'out of sight, out of mind', and the world conspires to keep our minds off the suffering of these animals. But it's well worthwhile taking steps to lessen the most intense suffering, especially battery farmed chickens, and keeping the issue alive.

Cheers
Catherine

Gaye from the Hunter said...

Hello Catherine,

I appreciate your thoughts, thank you.

Yes, I agree, there is not enough regulation or information regarding "free range eggs" and I too am skeptical of those labeled so that I buy at Woolworths.

I can get frozen organic free range chickens in town, but as far as I know, fresh is not available - disadvantages of rural/country living. The farmers' markets have started up again in Singleton, and I intend checking out just what produce is sold there.

Cheers,
Gaye